The Wellness Revolution Podcast with Amber Shaw
503. The Reason Your Messaging Isn’t Landing (And It’s Not What You Think)
LISTEN & SUBSCRIBE
What if the reason your content isn’t bringing in clients is because you’re trying TOO hard to sound different from every other coach?
I see this happen all the time, especially with coaches who have tons of experience, know they’re great at what they do, but still struggle to get consistent clients from social media.
In this episode of The Art of Pre-Selling, I’m pulling back the curtain on two coaching calls I had recently with women who were making almost the EXACT same messaging mistake. And the interesting part? Neither of them realized they were doing it.
Both coaches were trying so hard to communicate the deeper transformation they give their clients that they were overlooking the very thing their ideal clients were actually looking for help with.
And that’s where we get into something I see coaches resist ALL the time: leading with the simple, sometimes even “vanilla,” problem their clients want solved.
I’m breaking down why your niche doesn’t need to sound fancy or completely different to attract paying clients, why the problem YOU know your client has isn’t always the problem SHE thinks she has, and where your unique approach actually comes into play.
Plus, I’m sharing real examples from weight loss, anxiety, dating, and burnout coaching so you can see how this applies to your own business. And I’ve got a quick messaging audit you can do this week to figure out whether your content is speaking to what your ideal client is actually searching for.
What I Discuss:
- 01:10 What happened when I asked a health coach what problem she actually solves
- 04:27 Why you don’t need to reinvent the problems people have to stand out
- 04:58 How a conversation with a dating coach revealed the fear of sounding too “vanilla”
- 08:58 Why I’d rather you speak to the problem your ideal client is Googling at night than the deeper transformation she doesn’t even know she needs yet
- 09:39 Another coach, a similar messaging problem, and what happened when we got to the real reason her clients were seeking help
- 11:20 Why experienced coaches sometimes resist straightforward labels like “weight loss coach”
- 13:30 How to recognize when you’re dancing around the problem your ideal client already knows she has instead of speaking directly to it
- 14:09 Examples across niches
- 16:48 The simple audit on your Instagram bio, your last five posts, and the language your clients use when they first come to you
Find more from Amber Shaw:
Instagram: @msambershaw
Website: ambershaw.com

